1209 SEA PLUME WAY

House For Sale

$1,500,000

BTC: 18.04185711

ETH: 566.03773585

4 days

For Sale

House

3 bds •

3 ba •

2,082 sqft

Overview

Virtually Staged. Old Florida Charm on Siesta Key's Quiet South End Hidden beneath a canopy of mature tropical trees on one of South Siesta Key's most desirable residential streets, this distinctive three-story home captures the timeless character and charm that make island living so special. Located within a small enclave of established homes where short-term vacation rentals are restricted, the neighborhood is known for its lush landscaping, beautiful waterfront residences, and authentic sense of community that has become increasingly rare on Siesta Key. Thoughtfully spread across three levels, the home blends timeless coastal architecture with modern updates. Exposed wood beams, a fireplace, and an abundance of outdoor living spaces give the residence a sense of warmth and character rarely found in newer construction. Multiple terraces provide private places to relax throughout the day, while the newly built Trex rooftop deck elevates the experience with sweeping sunset views and refreshing Gulf breezes. Offering 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a two-car garage, a newer metal roof, high-velocity HVAC system, Hardi board siding, and a generously sized fenced yard, the property strikes a balance between charm, functionality, and laid-back island living. Just a short walk to Point of Rocks, beach access, South Siesta Village, Captain Curt's, Crescent Beach Market, the Crescent Club, and other local favorites, the location places the best of Siesta Key at your doorstep. Spend your days exploring the island by bike, trolley, or on foot, with Siesta Key Beach, Turtle Beach, waterfront dining, and endless coastal activities all nearby. Whether it's a morning walk along the shore, an afternoon spent enjoying the island's vibrant beach culture, or sunset from the rooftop deck, this home is perfectly positioned to experience everything that has made Siesta Key one of Florida's most beloved destinations. Properties like this are becoming increasingly difficult to find on Siesta Key. Combining architectural character, modern improvements, walkability to the beach and dining, a large private yard, and a neighborhood centered around homeowners rather than vacation rentals, this is a rare opportunity to enjoy the authentic charm of island living on the quieter south end of the Key.

Location

Florida • SARASOTA • 34242 • House • For Sale

Details

Type:

Residential

Parking:

Driveway

Year Built:

1977

Lot:

0.25 Acres

Heating:

Central / Electric

Price/sqft:

$720

Cooling:

Central Air / Mini-Split Unit(s) / Other

HOA:

$600

Type:

Residential

Parking:

Driveway

Year Built:

1977

Lot:

0.25 Acres

Heating:

Central / Electric

Price/sqft:

$720

Cooling:

Central Air / Mini-Split Unit(s) / Other

HOA:

$600

Private inquiry

Talk to the advisor on this listing.

Floor plans, HOA docs, off-market comparables, scheduling a private showing — one message, direct to the local specialist.

Valuation

Our model vs. what's actually selling nearby.

Estimate

$674,499

$402K – $1.2M

Confidence Low

List vs. estimate

$825K above estimate

List $1,500,000 · +122.4%

Our model says this listing is priced above recent comparable activity. Room to negotiate.

Price per sq ft

$720

+131.3% vs. city median $311

Based on

6 MLS comparables

Median of recent comparable listings. Sold comps use closing price, active listings use list price.

Highlights

Annual tax

$9,006

2025

HOA

$600/yr

Common Area Taxes, Insurance, Private Road

View

Trees/Woods

Garage

2 car garage

Pets

Allowed

All facts and features

Flooring

• Carpet

• Ceramic Tile

• Hardwood

Heating

• Central

• Electric

Cooling

• Central Air

• Mini-Split Unit(s)

• Other

Appliances

• Built-In Oven

• Cooktop

• Dishwasher

• Disposal

• Dryer

• Electric Water Heater

• Exhaust Fan

• Microwave

Other interior features

• Cathedral Ceiling(s)

• Ceiling Fan(s)

• Eating Space In Kitchen

• High Ceilings

• Living Room/Dining Room Combo

• Thermostat

• Vaulted Ceiling(s)

• Walk-In Closet(s)

Bedrooms and bathrooms

• Bedrooms: 3

• Full bathrooms: 3
Parking

• Driveway

Property

• Levels: Three Or More

• Exterior Features: Balcony / Lighting / Private Entrance / Private Yard

Lot

• Lot: 0.25 Acres

Other Property Information

• Parcel Number: 0108160017

• Zoning: RSF2
Type and style

• Property Type: Residential

• Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Utility

• Cable Available

• Electricity Connected

• Public

• Sewer Connected

• Water Connected
Other financial information

• HOA: $600

• HOA Frequency: Annually

• Annual tax amount: $9,006
Source details

• MLS ID: N6145583

Other facts

• Construction Materials: HardiPlank Type / Wood Frame

• Foundation Details: Other

• Fireplace Features: Electric / Insert

• Laundry Features: Inside / Laundry Room

• Lot Features: FloodZone / Landscaped / Private / Street Dead-End

• Patio And Porch Features: Covered / Deck / Front Porch / Other / Patio / Porch / Rear Porch / Side Porch

• Direction Faces: Southwest

• Architectural Style: Key West

• Fireplace: Yes

• Garage Spaces: 2

• Attached Garage: Yes

• Garage: Yes

• Living Area: 2082

• Water Source: Public

• Subdivision Name: MANGROVES SUB THE

Private inquiry

Talk to the advisor on this listing.

Floor plans, HOA docs, off-market comparables, scheduling a private showing — one message, direct to the local specialist.

More like this

For Sale

$1,400,000

House

4 bds · 2 ba · 1,659 sqft

OCEAN VIEW, SARASOTA

8302 MIDNIGHT PASS ROAD

2 bds · 2 ba · 1,956 sqft

RIVER FOREST, SARASOTA

5381 PALOS VERDES DRIVE

3 bds · 2 ba · 2,850 sqft

BISHOPS COURT AT OAKS PRESERVE, OSPREY

17 BAYHEAD LANE

For Sale

$1,349,000

3 bds · 3 ba · 1,900 sqft

SIESTA KEY BEACH RESIDENCES II, SARASOTA

915 SEASIDE DRIVE UNIT 310

For Sale

$1,599,000

Condo/Co-op

3 bds · 3 ba · 2,080 sqft

TIFFANY SANDS, SARASOTA

548 BEACH ROAD UNIT A

For Sale

$1,150,000

House

4 bds · 2 ba · 2,288 sqft

SIESTA BEACH, SARASOTA

5157 SANDY BEACH AVENUE

For Sale

$1,250,000

House

4 bds · 2 ba · 1,700 sqft

MIRA MAR BEACH EXT, SARASOTA

3 bds · 2 ba · 2,123 sqft

PHILLIPPI GARDENS 04, SARASOTA

2303 CONSTITUTION BOULEVARD

Market around this address

Live counts in the same area.

The multiple listing information is provided by the Stellar MLS from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are ©2026-present Stellar MLS. All Rights Reserved. The information provided is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All properties are subject to prior sale or withdrawal. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate, and should be independently verified. Listing courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

1209 SEA PLUME WAY

Overview

Location

Details

Valuation

Highlights

Interior details

Property details

Construction details

Utilities / Green Energy Details

HOA and Financial Details

Other

More like this

Market around this address