Sell Your Home
Get a free home valuation
Contact
Tell us about your needs

136 ISLAND COTTAGE WAY WAY

House For Sale
$749,000

BTC: 9.62539356

ETH: 312.08333333

8 days
3 bds
2 ba
1,838 sqft

Overview

Welcome to 136 Island Cottage Way, an exceptional residence within Island Cottages — an exclusive gated enclave of just 23 homes on Anastasia Island. Majestic oaks frame the entrance, while refined coastal architecture defines this private, serene community, mere minutes from pristine beaches and the historic charm of St. Augustine. Distinguished as one of only two single-story homes in the neighborhood, this residence embodies timeless Key West-inspired coastal elegance. A welcoming front porch, classic white picket fence, metal roof, and thoughtfully designed landscape lighting create outstanding curb appeal and island character. Convenient rear-alley access leads to the two-car garage, preserving the home’s graceful front elevation. Situated at a desirable elevation in Flood Zone X, the home has been meticulously updated throughout. Recent enhancements include fresh exterior paint, new flooring, elegantly renovated bathrooms, and a refined kitchen featuring quartz countertops, ceiling-height cabinetry with convenient pull-outs, a counter-depth refrigerator, and a separate beverage refrigerator — ideal for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. An on-demand water heater adds modern efficiency and comfort. The primary suite bathroom stands as a true spa-like sanctuary. Plantation shutters and remote-operated blinds deliver sophisticated style, privacy, and ease throughout. Additional luxury appointments include custom closet systems, ceiling fans, a water softener, washer and dryer, security cameras, and a full complement of kitchen appliances (range, dishwasher, disposal, and microwave). The rear-entry two-car garage is finished with an epoxy floor, built-in cabinetry, and generous storage, elevating organization and everyday functionality. Island Cottages offers the ultimate low-maintenance lifestyle. The HOA maintains the landscaping, creating an ideal lock-and-go residence whether as a primary home or refined second residence. Residents also enjoy the beautiful community pool without the responsibility of private pool ownership. With its rare single-story floor plan, beautifully updated interiors, elevated Flood Zone X location, gated privacy, distinctive Key West-inspired character, and effortless coastal lifestyle, 136 Island Cottage Way presents a rare opportunity to experience the very best of Anastasia Island living — refined, convenient, and unmistakably luxurious.

Location

Details

Type:
Residential
Parking:
No Data
Year Built:
2005
Lot:
0.11 Acres
Heating:
Central / Electric / Heat Pump
Price/sqft:
$408
Cooling:
Central Air
HOA:
$400

Valuation

Our model vs. what's actually selling nearby.
Estimate
$545,000
$252K – $816K
Confidence Low
List vs. estimate
$204K above estimate
List $749,000 · +37.4%
Our model says this listing is priced above recent comparable activity. Room to negotiate.
Price per sq ft
$407
+42.3% vs. city median $286
Based on
8 MLS comparables
Median of recent comparable listings. Sold comps use closing price, active listings use list price.

Highlights

Annual tax
$6,248
2025
HOA
$400/mo
Garage
2 car garage
Pets
Allowed
All facts and features
  • Flooring

    • Luxury Vinyl

    • Tile

    Heating

    • Central

    • Electric

    • Heat Pump

    Cooling

    • Central Air

    Appliances

    • Dishwasher

    • Disposal

    • Dryer

    • Microwave

    • Range

    • Refrigerator

    • Tankless Water Heater

    • Washer

    • Wine Refrigerator

    Other interior features

    • Cathedral Ceiling(s)

    • Ceiling Fan(s)

    • High Ceilings

    • Living Room/Dining Room Combo

    • Open Floorplan

    • Primary Bedroom Main Floor

    • Solid Surface Counters

    • Walk-In Closet(s)

    • Window Treatments

    Bedrooms and bathrooms

    • Bedrooms: 3

    • Full bathrooms: 2

  • Property

    • Levels: One

    • Exterior Features: French Doors / Irrigation System / Lighting / Outdoor Shower / Sidewalk

    Lot

    • Lot: 0.11 Acres

    Other Property Information

    • Parcel Number: 1758090040

    • Zoning: RES

  • Type and style

    • Property Type: Residential

    • Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

  • Utility

    • Cable Connected

    • Electricity Connected

    • Fiber Optics

    • Sewer Connected

    • Street Lights

    • Underground Utilities

    • Water Connected

  • Other financial information

    • HOA: $400

    • HOA Frequency: Monthly

    • Annual tax amount: $6,249

  • Source details

    • MLS ID: FC320687

    Other facts

    • Construction Materials: Block / HardiPlank Type

    • Foundation Details: Slab / Stem Wall

    • Laundry Features: Inside / Laundry Closet

    • Window Features: Shades / Window Treatments

    • Direction Faces: South

    • Garage Spaces: 2

    • Attached Garage: Yes

    • Garage: Yes

    • Living Area: 1838

    • Water Source: Public

    • Lot Size Dimensions: 50 x 94

    • Subdivision Name: ISLAND COTTAGES

Private inquiry
Talk to the advisor on this listing.
Floor plans, HOA docs, off-market comparables, scheduling a private showing — one message, direct to the local specialist.

More like this

New
For Sale
$729,900
House
4 bds · 4 ba · 2,904 sqft
ESTATES/TUSCANY PH 02A, ST AUGUSTINE
533 CHRISTINA DRIVE
New
For Sale
$599,900
House
3 bds · 2 ba · 1,280 sqft
MICKLERS SUB, ST AUGUSTINE
5466 4TH STREET
For Sale
$600,000
Condo/Co-op
2 bds · 2 ba · 1,129 sqft
ST AUGUSTINE BEACH & TENNIS CL, ST AUGUSTINE
4 OCEAN TRACE ROAD UNIT 104
-$25K
For Sale
$759,900
House
3 bds · 2 ba · 2,004 sqft
LE JARDIN DE LA BEAUCE, ST AUGUSTINE
287 BOULEVARD DES PINS
-$10K
For Sale
$789,000
House
4 bds · 2 ba · 1,975 sqft
08-98 WINDSWEPT ACRES, ST AUGUSTINE
5398 SOUNDVIEW AVENUE
For Sale
$524,900
Condo/Co-op
2 bds · 2 ba · 1,200 sqft
ANASTASIA CONDOMINIUMS, ST AUGUSTINE
2 DONDANVILLE ROAD UNIT 112

Market around this address

Live counts in the same area.
View all

The multiple listing information is provided by the Stellar MLS from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are ©2026-present Stellar MLS. All Rights Reserved. The information provided is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All properties are subject to prior sale or withdrawal. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate, and should be independently verified. Listing courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS (ST. AUG)