Sell Your Home
Get a free home valuation
Contact
Tell us about your needs

5157 SANDY BEACH AVENUE

House For Sale
$1,150,000

BTC: 14.62174189

ETH: 454.45564118

2 days
4 bds
2 ba
2,288 sqft

Overview

Experience the relaxed Siesta Key lifestyle in this spacious Key West-inspired pool home, ideally located on a quiet street approximately one mile from Siesta Key Village and just minutes from the island’s world-famous beaches. Restaurants, shops, nightlife, and local favorites such as LeLu Coffee Lounge are all within an easy bike ride. Offering four bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms, the home features a large, open living area and a generous kitchen with a breakfast bar—perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The main-level primary suite includes a private en-suite bathroom and direct access to the pool area. Upstairs, three additional bedrooms provide plenty of space for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, the private backyard and heated in-ground pool create a secluded tropical setting for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying Florida’s year-round sunshine. With its desirable island location, flexible floor plan, and distinctive Key West character, this home offers an excellent opportunity to update and personalize a Siesta Key residence to your own style.

Location

Details

Type:
Residential
Parking:
No Data
Year Built:
1992
Lot:
0.18 Acres
Heating:
Electric
Price/sqft:
$503
Cooling:
Central Air
HOA:
No Data

Valuation

Our model vs. what's actually selling nearby.
Estimate
$599,000
$399K – $712K
Confidence Low
List vs. estimate
$551K above estimate
List $1,150,000 · +92.0%
Our model says this listing is priced above recent comparable activity. Room to negotiate.
Price per sq ft
$502
+56.0% vs. city median $322
Based on
24 MLS comparables
Median of recent comparable listings. Sold comps use closing price, active listings use list price.

Highlights

Annual tax
$8,640
2025
Pool
Heated
Garage
2 car garage
Furnished
Furnished
Pets
Allowed
All facts and features
  • Flooring

    • Carpet

    • Hardwood

    Heating

    • Electric

    Cooling

    • Central Air

    Appliances

    • Dishwasher

    • Disposal

    • Dryer

    • Electric Water Heater

    • Microwave

    • Range

    • Refrigerator

    • Washer

    Other interior features

    • Cathedral Ceiling(s)

    • Ceiling Fan(s)

    • Primary Bedroom Main Floor

    Bedrooms and bathrooms

    • Bedrooms: 4

    • Bathrooms: 1

    • Full bathrooms: 2

  • Property

    • Levels: Two

    • Pool Private: Yes

    • Exterior Features: None

    Lot

    • Lot: 0.18 Acres

    Other Property Information

    • Parcel Number: 0081150051

  • Type and style

    • Property Type: Residential

    • Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

  • Utility

    • Electricity Connected

  • Other financial information

    • Annual tax amount: $8,640

  • Source details

    • MLS ID: A4705681

    Other facts

    • Construction Materials: Wood Frame

    • Foundation Details: Stilt/On Piling

    • Laundry Features: Laundry Room

    • Pool Features: Heated / In Ground

    • Direction Faces: West

    • Garage Spaces: 2

    • Attached Garage: Yes

    • Garage: Yes

    • Living Area: 2288

    • Water Source: Public

    • Subdivision Name: SIESTA BEACH

Private inquiry
Talk to the advisor on this listing.
Floor plans, HOA docs, off-market comparables, scheduling a private showing — one message, direct to the local specialist.

More like this

For Sale
$1,000,000
Lots/Land
0.30 acres
SIESTA REV OF, SARASOTA
226 OGDEN STREET
New
For Sale
$1,100,000
Lots/Land
0.53 acres
SANDERLING CLUB/SIESTA PROPERTIES INC, SARASOTA
7219 PINE NEEDLE ROAD
New
For Sale
$1,495,000
House
3 bds · 3 ba · 1,824 sqft
POINSETTIA PARK, SARASOTA
1907 MAGNOLIA STREET
New
For Sale
$1,495,000
Lots/Land
0.80 acres
SIESTA PROPERTIES INC, SARASOTA
7340 PINE NEEDLE ROAD
New
For Sale
$1,075,000
Multi-family
6 bds · 2,450 sqft
ROSELAWN, SARASOTA
2047 ROSELAWN STREET
New
For Sale
$839,000
Condo/Co-op
2 bds · 2 ba · 1,248 sqft
LIDO HARBOUR SOUTH, SARASOTA
2110 BENJAMIN FRANKLIN DRIVE UNIT 104
New
For Sale
$1,300,000
House
3 bds · 2 ba · 1,542 sqft
SIESTA BEACH, SARASOTA
801 EDGEMERE LANE
New
For Sale
$1,199,000
Condo/Co-op
3 bds · 3 ba · 1,743 sqft
SARASOTA BATH AND RACQUET CLUB, A CONDOMINIUM, SARASOTA
2170 ROBINHOOD STREET UNIT A2-305

Market around this address

Live counts in the same area.
View all

The multiple listing information is provided by the Stellar MLS from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are ©2026-present Stellar MLS. All Rights Reserved. The information provided is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All properties are subject to prior sale or withdrawal. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate, and should be independently verified. Listing courtesy of: M&M PROPERTY MANAGEMENT GROUP