Contact
Tell us about your needs

Real Estate Market Trends and Analytics in Long Key, FL

In May 2025, Long Key, FL homes were selling for an average price of $658,333, Long Key, FL homes on average sell after 66 days on the market compared to 59 days last year. There were 6 homes sold in Long Key, FL for May 2025, compared to 2 last year.
View all properties for sale in Long Key, FL

Long Key, FL Market Trend

Average List Price
The average list price of Long Key, FL, was $1,588,300 in May 2025, compared to $589,000 in May 2024.

Long Key, FL Market Trend for Houses

Average List Price
The average list price of houses in Long Key, FL, was $1,272,875 in May 2025, compared to $589,000 in May 2024.

Long Key, FL Market Trend for Condos / Townhouses / Penthouses

Average List Price
The average list price of condos/co-ops in Long Key, FL, was $0 in May 2025, compared to $0 in May 2024.

Long Key, FL Market Trend for Lots/Land

Average List Price
The average list price of lots/land in Long Key, FL, was $5,250,000 in May 2025, compared to $0 in May 2024.

Long Key, FL Market Trend for Commercial

Average List Price
The average list price of commercial in Long Key, FL, was $0 in May 2025, compared to $0 in May 2024.

Long Key, FL Housing Market Analysis

The average list price in Long Key, FL is $1,588,300. The average list price in Long Key, FL went up 212.04% from 2024 to 2025. Long Key, FL home resale inventories is 10, which increased 233.33% since 2024. The average list price per square foot in Long Key, FL is $619. 2024 it was $791.
10
for sale
4
for rent
8
sold
Price Range
$350K - $5.2M
Avg. SQFT Price
$619
SF Range
510 - 7,941 SF
Beds
1 - 7
Avg. Dom
78 days
Year Built
1972 - 2007

Properties in Long Key, FL

65821 Overseas Hwy #12, Long Key FL 33001 placeholder 65821 Overseas Hwy #12, Long Key FL 33001
18 days
For Sale
House
$400,000
1 bds 1 ba 510 sqft
65821 Overseas Hwy #12, Long Key FL 33001
65890 Overseas Hwy, Long Key FL 33001 placeholder 65890 Overseas Hwy, Long Key FL 33001
24 days
For Sale
House
$5,245,000
7 bds 6 ba 7,941 sqft
65890 Overseas Hwy, Long Key FL 33001
65821 Overseas Highway, Lot 375, Long Key FL 33001 placeholder 65821 Overseas Highway, Lot 375, Long Key FL 33001
-$39K (2025/05/05)
For Sale
House
$350,000
2 bds 1 ba 574 sqft
65821 Overseas Highway, Lot 375, Long Key FL 33001
65821 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY UNIT 314 placeholder 65821 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY UNIT 314
35 days
For Sale
$450,000
1 bds 1 ba 624 sqft
65821 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY UNIT 314
65821 Overseas Hwy # 232, Long Key FL 33001 placeholder 65821 Overseas Hwy # 232, Long Key FL 33001
99 days
For Sale
House
$445,000
1 bds 1 ba
65821 Overseas Hwy # 232, Long Key FL 33001
65821 Overseas Highway 98, Long Key FL 33001 placeholder 65821 Overseas Highway 98, Long Key FL 33001
100 days
For Sale
House
$489,000
2 bds 1 ba
65821 Overseas Highway 98, Long Key FL 33001
65821 Overseas Highway 75, Long Key FL 33001 placeholder 65821 Overseas Highway 75, Long Key FL 33001
100 days
For Sale
House
$889,000
2 bds 1 ba
65821 Overseas Highway 75, Long Key FL 33001
109 S Layton Dr, Long Key FL 33001 placeholder 109 S Layton Dr, Long Key FL 33001
-$75K (2025/05/09)
For Sale
House
$1,125,000
3 bds 2 ba 2,160 sqft
109 S Layton Dr, Long Key FL 33001

Market Trends nearby