In September 2026, the median home sale price in Big Pine Key (33043), FL was $784,000, with homes selling in an average of 86 days — faster than the 140-day average last year, indicating stronger demand. A total of 10 homes sold in this period, up from 9 last year — a sign of an active market.
The median list price of Big Pine Key (33043), FL, was $975,000 in September 2026, compared to $850,000 in September 2025.
Big Pine Key (33043), FL Market Trend for Houses
Median List Price
The median list price of houses in Big Pine Key (33043), FL, was $1,162,500 in September 2026, compared to $899,000 in September 2025.
Big Pine Key (33043), FL Market Trend for Condos / Townhouses / Penthouses
Median List Price
The median list price of condos/co-ops in Big Pine Key (33043), FL, was $0 in September 2026, compared to $0 in September 2025.
Big Pine Key (33043), FL Market Trend for Lots/Land
Median List Price
The median list price of lots/land in Big Pine Key (33043), FL, was $595,000 in September 2026, compared to $595,000 in September 2025.
Big Pine Key (33043), FL Market Trend for Commercial
Median List Price
The median list price of commercial in Big Pine Key (33043), FL, was $1,025,000 in September 2026, compared to $850,000 in September 2025.
Big Pine Key (33043), FL Housing Market Analysis
There are currently 21 homes listed for sale in Big Pine Key (33043), FL, an increase of 320.00% compared to 2025. With more homes on the market than are selling each month, buyers may find more options and room to negotiate. The median asking price is $1,510,048 (up 0.89% year-over-year), and the average price per square foot is $779 compared to $851 in 2025. Properties spend an average of 148 days on the market before going under contract.
