Sell Your Home
Get a free home valuation
Contact
Tell us about your needs

217 W BAY STREET

House For Sale
$1,395,000

BTC: 21.73248911

ETH: 791.29181935

-$100K (2026/06/15)
44 days
5 bds
4 ba
2,800 sqft

Overview

LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Experience the best of Historic Winter Garden living in this brand-new Craftsman-style home, ideally located just steps from downtown dining, shopping, entertainment, and the renowned West Orange Trail. Originally a charming 1950s bungalow, the 576 sq. ft. home has been completely renovated and thoughtfully expanded into a stunning 2,800 sq. ft. residence offering 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and exceptional modern upgrades throughout. Relax on the inviting front porch and enjoy the charm and atmosphere of this idyllic golf cart community. Inside, a bright and spacious open floor plan welcomes you with designer finishes, 10-foot ceilings, luxury waterproof vinyl plank flooring, plantation shutters, 8-foot doors, and elegant architectural details throughout. The heart of the home is the spectacular chef’s kitchen featuring premium LG stainless steel appliances, built-in oven and microwave, induction cooktop, wine fridge, oversized island with seating and storage, 42” refrigerator, and an enormous walk-in pantry complete with an additional retro-style refrigerator. The adjoining family room showcases a custom fireplace with built-in storage and two sets of French doors opening to a large covered lanai with summer kitchen, overlooking the beautifully landscaped and fully fenced backyard with additional deck space for entertaining and relaxing. The luxurious primary suite offers custom walk-in closets, a spa-inspired en-suite bath, and private French doors leading to a secluded patio and deck area. A separate lower-level wing includes two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and utility room, creating endless possibilities for an in-law suite, home office, theater room, or private guest retreat. Upstairs, you’ll find two spacious bedrooms, including one with en-suite bath, an additional full bath, linen storage, and generous extra storage space. Additional highlights include a covered carport with EV charging outlet, oversized driveway with parking for at least 6 cars, 2-zone A/C system, gutters with leaf guards, upgraded lighting, charming picket fencing, lush landscaping, and a 10x8 storage/workshop. Live the coveted Winter Garden lifestyle with golf cart access to charming boutiques, restaurants, breweries, parks, the weekly farmers market, Lake Apopka, splash pad, and more. This exceptional home perfectly combines historic charm with luxurious modern living in one of Central Florida’s most sought-after communities. Don’t miss this rare opportunity!

Location

Details

Type:
Residential
Parking:
Covered / Driveway / Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s)
Year Built:
2025
Lot:
0.17 Acres
Heating:
Central / Electric
Price/sqft:
$498
Cooling:
Central Air
HOA:
No Data

Valuation

Our model vs. what's actually selling nearby.
Estimate
$657,762
$619K – $1.1M
Confidence Low
List vs. estimate
$737K above estimate
List $1,395,000 · +112.1%
Our model says this listing is priced above recent comparable activity. Room to negotiate.
Price per sq ft
$498
+83.3% vs. city median $271
Based on
24 MLS comparables
Median of recent comparable listings. Sold comps use closing price, active listings use list price.

Highlights

Annual tax
$5,958
2025
Pets
Allowed
All facts and features
  • Flooring

    • Luxury Vinyl

    Heating

    • Central

    • Electric

    Cooling

    • Central Air

    Appliances

    • Microwave

    • Built-In Oven

    • Refrigerator

    • Washer

    • Cooktop

    • Dishwasher

    • Disposal

    • Dryer

    • Electric Water Heater

    • Exhaust Fan

    • Wine Refrigerator

    Other interior features

    • Eating Space In Kitchen

    • High Ceilings

    • Open Floorplan

    • Primary Bedroom Main Floor

    • Solid Surface Counters

    • Split Bedroom

    • Walk-In Closet(s)

    • Window Treatments

    • Built-in Features

    • Ceiling Fan(s)

    • Chair Rail

    Bedrooms and bathrooms

    • Bedrooms: 5

    • Full bathrooms: 4

  • Parking

    • Covered

    • Driveway

    • Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s)

    Property

    • Levels: Two

    • Exterior Features: French Doors / Garden / Irrigation System / Lighting / Outdoor Grill / Outdoor Kitchen / Private Yard / Rain Gutters / Storage

    Lot

    • Lot: 0.17 Acres

    Other Property Information

    • Parcel Number: 142227172805191

    • Zoning: R-2

  • Type and style

    • Property Type: Residential

    • Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

  • Utility

    • BB/HS Internet Available

    • Public

    • Sewer Connected

    • Water Connected

    • Cable Connected

    • Electricity Connected

  • Other financial information

    • Annual tax amount: $5,958

  • Source details

    • MLS ID: S5149527

    Other facts

    • Construction Materials: Block / Stucco / Vinyl Siding

    • Foundation Details: Slab

    • Fireplace Features: Electric

    • Laundry Features: Laundry Room

    • Window Features: Shutters / Double Pane Windows

    • Direction Faces: East

    • Fireplace: Yes

    • Water Body Name: LAKE APOPKA

    • Living Area: 2800

    • Water Source: Public

    • Subdivision Name: COOPER & SEWELL ADD

Private inquiry
Talk to the advisor on this listing.
Floor plans, HOA docs, off-market comparables, scheduling a private showing — one message, direct to the local specialist.

More like this

New
For Sale
$1,200,000
House
5 bds · 4 ba · 4,225 sqft
BRADFORD CREEK PHASE II, WINTER GARDEN
14312 SUNBRIDGE CIRCLE
New
For Sale
$1,725,000
House
4 bds · 3 ba · 3,243 sqft
G T SMITH SUB 2, WINTER GARDEN
121 W MAPLE STREET
New
For Sale
$1,175,000
House
4 bds · 3 ba · 2,667 sqft
OAKLAND PARK, WINTER GARDEN
925 EASLEY AVENUE
For Sale
$1,137,150
House
4 bds · 3 ba · 2,995 sqft
LAKEVIEW VILLAGE ESTATES, WINTER GARDEN
642 MEDORA WAY
For Sale
$1,157,190
House
4 bds · 3 ba · 2,902 sqft
LAKEVIEW VILLAGE ESTATES, WINTER GARDEN
650 MEDORA WAY
For Sale
$1,149,000
House
4 bds · 3 ba · 2,729 sqft
WINTER GARDEN SHORES FIRST ADD, WINTER GARDEN
20 E DIVISION STREET
For Sale
$1,200,000
House
4 bds · 3 ba · 3,512 sqft
LAKE COVE POINTE 46/58, WINTER GARDEN
440 TIERRA VERDE LANE
For Sale
$1,000,000
House
4 bds · 3 ba · 3,828 sqft
CYPRESS RESERVE PH 1, WINTER GARDEN
13822 JOMATT LOOP

Market around this address

Live counts in the same area.
View all

The multiple listing information is provided by the Stellar MLS from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are ©2026-present Stellar MLS. All Rights Reserved. The information provided is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All properties are subject to prior sale or withdrawal. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate, and should be independently verified. Listing courtesy of: WATSON REALTY CORP.