In September 2026, the median home sale price in Umatilla, FL was $304,190, with homes selling in an average of 107 days — slower than the 94-day average last year, suggesting buyers have more negotiating room. A total of 258 homes sold in this period, down from 287 last year.
The median list price of Umatilla, FL, was $295,000 in September 2026, compared to $308,195 in September 2025.
Umatilla, FL Market Trend for Houses
Median List Price
The median list price of houses in Umatilla, FL, was $353,990 in September 2026, compared to $343,124 in September 2025.
Umatilla, FL Market Trend for Condos / Townhouses / Penthouses
Median List Price
The median list price of condos/co-ops in Umatilla, FL, was $0 in September 2026, compared to $0 in September 2025.
Umatilla, FL Market Trend for Lots/Land
Median List Price
The median list price of lots/land in Umatilla, FL, was $122,450 in September 2026, compared to $157,450 in September 2025.
Umatilla, FL Market Trend for Commercial
Median List Price
The median list price of commercial in Umatilla, FL, was $686,500 in September 2026, compared to $372,500 in September 2025.
Umatilla, FL Housing Market Analysis
There are currently 149 homes listed for sale in Umatilla, FL, an increase of 35.45% compared to 2025. With inventory tight relative to sales volume, sellers are in a strong position. The median asking price is $462,467 (up 31.55% year-over-year), and the average price per square foot is $208 compared to $179 in 2025. Properties spend an average of 174 days on the market before going under contract.
