In January 2026, Sumter County homes were selling for an average price of $380,679, Sumter County homes on average sell after 83 days on the market compared to 69 days last year. There were 4114 homes sold in Sumter County for January 2026, compared to 4358 last year.
The average list price of Sumter County, was $573,724 in January 2026, compared to $537,967 in January 2025.
Sumter County Market Trend for Houses
Average List Price
The average list price of houses in Sumter County, was $471,820 in January 2026, compared to $419,745 in January 2025.
Sumter County Market Trend for Condos / Townhouses / Penthouses
Average List Price
The average list price of condos/co-ops in Sumter County, was $257,185 in January 2026, compared to $251,705 in January 2025.
Sumter County Market Trend for Lots/Land
Average List Price
The average list price of lots/land in Sumter County, was $804,260 in January 2026, compared to $1,097,858 in January 2025.
Sumter County Market Trend for Commercial
Average List Price
The average list price of commercial in Sumter County, was $1,149,411 in January 2026, compared to $956,575 in January 2025.
Sumter County Housing Market Analysis
The average list price in Sumter County is $573,724. The average list price in Sumter County went up 9.16% from 2025 to 2026. Sumter County home resale inventories is 1732, which increased 13.28% since 2025. The average list price per square foot in Sumter County is $262. 2025 it was $224.
