Sell Your Home
Get a free home valuation
Contact
Tell us about your needs

Bay Harbor Islands

Bay Harbor Islands, Florida, 33154, US

Miami-Dade County
166
for sale
107
for rent
114
sold
Median Price
$1.4M
Median SQFT Price
$902
SF Range
395 - 8,016 SF
Beds
1 - 8
Avg. Dom
143 days
Year Built
1950 - 2027

Overview

Bay Harbor Islands is a suburb in Miami-Dade County. It is one of the top places to live in South Florida. It offers the residents an urban lifestyle. It has several cafes, shops, parks, and restaurants. The good thing is that all these establishments are within walking distance.

 

Let's check what makes Bay Harbor Islands a fantastic place to love. Then, we will give you an overview of what to expect when you decide to move and live in the Bay Harbor Islands.

 

For most locals, the beach is a 10-minute walk. This neighborhood is always bright and sunny. Your hat, sunglasses, and sunscreen should be handy.

 

Anyone can walk from their home to anywhere they need to go. If you prefer less walking, some canals flow through Bay Harbor. Many take their boats or rent boats nearby. They spend a whole day on the water. One can see water all around the community whether you drive or walk.

 

Bay Harbor Islands is a peaceful neighborhood. It is perfect for families and retirees. There is a sense of belongingness and community ideal for families here. There are many schools with high ratings, too. Thus, families with schoolchildren will enjoy living in this town, too.

 

Peaceful Neighborhood Bay Harbor Islands

 

This dense neighborhood offers different housing options, especially waterfront properties. There are condominiums, townhouses, single-family homes, and more. At present, new luxurious developments are coming up in the town as well as nearby beaches.

 

The results of Niche’s rankings for the Bay Harbor Islands neighborhood are as follows:

 

• #23 of 380 for Best Suburbs for Young Professionals in Florida;

• #30 of 380 for Best Suburbs to Raise a Family in Florida;

• #36 of 380 for Best Suburbs to Live in Florida.

 

Pretty impressive, right?!

 

Brief History

 

Shepard Broad, a Belarusian-born banker, lawyer, and philanthropist, was behind the idea. He bought the two deserted mangrove islands. It was during the post-war development period in Miami. The original names of the islands were Broadview (West) and Bay Harbor (East).

 

The incorporation into a town as ‘Bay Harbor Islands’ was in 1947.

 

Location

 

Bay Harbor Islands’ coverage is less than half a square mile. This small town is between 2 bigger cities, Miami Beach to the South and Aventura to the North.

 

The Bay Harbor Islands are two small islets, much like the shape of kidneys. They are in the north archipelago of small islands surrounding Biscayne Bay. Bay Harbor Islands is in the East of North Miami. Bal Harbor and Surfside, two other famous cities, are on its West side.

 

But despite the size of the Bay Harbor Islands, most will agree that this city features the best of both worlds. The area’s varied attractions are such an easy walk or drive. But the hustle and bustle of nearby Downtown Miami is quite a distance away. Both a refuge and a fun place to be - this is what Bay Harbor Islands represents.

 

Bay Harbor Islands - Picturesque Corner of Florida

 

You Will Love Bay Harbor Islands Because of These:

 

• Food and Dining – Bay Harbor Islands is near Miami Beach, Aventura, and Bal Harbour. Food and dining are top destinations here. Whatever fare you like, they're here. Be it American, Asian, Vegan, Italian, or Peruvian - all are available here. Or check the nearby neighborhoods. Plus, most of the restaurants in this town offer scenic views. Thus, for sure, there will be a lot of selfies and food photos you can take. Bay Harbor Islands is not only known for its top restaurants in Miami. Explore the neighboring areas for more gastronomic delights and fantastic restaurants. You have the most convenient access to these places at any time.

 

• Miami Modern Architecture - Bay Harbor Islands is walkable in every way due to its small coverage. You will be in awe of several homes and buildings with the Miami Modern architecture of the 1940s to 1950s. Your surroundings have character. These unique structures lend brightness and beauty to everyday life. For sure, art lovers will feel this town's vibrant art vibe. If there's another advantage here, it must be the free bus service. Locals and visitors alike can travel to the neighboring areas. It follows the true Miami style, such as walking and short commutes. Convenience is the key.

 

• Shopping – Don't keep your hopes too high. There's no overload of shopping malls and boutiques here. The town boasts a few strip mall stores, though. Explore Kane Concourse at East Island for some retail therapy. They feature everything from modern furniture to jewelry and branded rugs. But bear in mind that Bay Harbor Islands is not a shopping haven. It is not like Aventura and Bal Harbour. Since these two areas are so near the town, you will still get the chance to shop till you drop out. Shopaholics are still in for many retail trips at their whim. Besides, public transport is available. This benefit provides an easy commute for shopping at the neighboring luxurious malls.

 

• Leisure/Outdoors - Are you excited about fun outdoors? What activities are on your mind? Of course, one of South Florida's favorite leisure activities is playing golf. For Bay Harbor Islands, golf is a leisure sport, too. But some tourists prefer adventures like cruising waterways by boat. Or they charter a twin or triple pontoon to explore the islands, then head out into Biscayne Bay.

 

Outdoor Activities at Bay Harbor Islands

 

Other Activities Worth Checking Out:

 

1. One typical adventure is going North to the Oleta State River Park for bird-watching. You can also cruise around South for the small islets in the bay's North half.

 

2. Explore jet skiing or charter fishing, as some rental companies are on North Bay Island. It is a short drive away.

 

3. Some of the best beaches are at the town’s northern extent at Bal Harbour. The area is worth a visit for its elegance and upscale vibe.

 

4. Some locals and guests go for beautiful tropical places. These are the areas with palm trees and lush gardens. One place to explore is Bay Harbor’s Broadview Drive, a west island for the green surroundings. It’s a great way to escape from the hustle and bustle of the big city.

 

This small town is sought-after with its parks, restaurants, and leisure spots. Locals enjoy their life here. Plus, the nearby beaches are relaxing and inviting. At the center of the fast-paced Miami Beach, Bay Harbor Islands is like a breath of fresh air. It is peaceful and friendly, plus the small-town feel is splendid. It is a desirable town to live in and raise a family. You can make it your retirement home. Or for those in business, the local economy is thriving well. You can always put up your stores here, too. The young professionals can own their first homes with modern condominium properties.

 

Whatever your reason, you will not regret moving and residing in Bay Harbor Islands.

💡 Did You Know?

Founded in 1947 by Shepard Broad, a Russian immigrant who arrived in the US at age 14 from Pinsk.
Two tiny kidney-shaped islands with their own police force — ranked 4th safest city in Florida.
Record sale: $12,800,000 changed hands at 10241 E BROADVIEW DR, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 in October 2025.
The area's oldest structure stands at 9650 E BAY HARBOR DR, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154, built in 1946.
Housing mix: 90% condos, 10% single-family homes.

Data powered by brokerone.io

Bay Harbor Islands Units For Sale

Status Bedrooms
No properties found

Bay Harbor Islands Real Estate Market Trends

Median List Price
The median list price of homes in Bay Harbor Islands, was $1,444,450 in June 2026, compared to $750,000 in June 2025.

Location

Bay Harbor Islands, Florida, 33154, US

Neighborhood Insights

Ownership & Property Data

Median Assessed Value $380K
Highest Assessed Value $35.3M

Top Property Owners

BAY HARBOR ISLANDS C/O THE CONTINUUM COMPANY $15.8M
FUED ELIAS SADALA JR SILVANE MARIA COELHO SADALA $12.4M
BAY HARBOR ISLANDS C/O THE CONTINUUM COMPANY $11.8M
SPENCER KUPFERMAN RUTH KUPFERMAN $11.1M
NOAH BURTON TRS THE ML MILANO 2022 FAMILY TR $10.8M

Foreclosure Risk Score

26/100 MODERATE
30-Year Mortgage Rate 6.23%
Local Unemployment 3.9%

Risk score based on economic indicators, lis pendens filings, and census data. Not financial advice.

Data powered by brokerone.io

Bay Harbor Islands Frequently Asked Questions

  • The Bay Harbor Islands neighborhood is located in the Miami-Dade County area.

  • The Bay Harbor Islands neighborhood belongs to the following categories: Waterfront, Luxury, Family Friendly, Exclusive.

  • Currently, there are 166 homes for sale in the Bay Harbor Islands neighborhood.

  • Currently, there are 107 homes for rent in the Bay Harbor Islands neighborhood.

  • 114 homes have been sold in the Bay Harbor Islands neighborhood in the last 12 months.

  • The square footage of homes in the Bay Harbor Islands neighborhood is from 395 to 8016 sq.ft.

Estimate your monthly payment here

Pre-filled with the median price for this area · Live Freddie Mac PMMS 6.49% as of Jun 25, 2026

Open full calculator →
$
%
Monthly Payment (PITI + HOA)
$0
% · Includes principal, interest, taxes & insurance
Run full numbers

Protect what you'll buy with Choice Home Warranty

Sponsored

Homeowner's insurance doesn't cover AC, water heater, or kitchen and laundry appliance breakdowns. Choice Home Warranty handles repair and replacement on one monthly plan — free quote in 30 seconds.

Get a free quote

We earn a commission when you sign up through some links on this page. It doesn't change which products we recommend or what they cost you.